I’ve been thinking about single purpose vs. multipurpose tools. One of the captivating features of my iPhone is the onboard digital camera. And I don’t even have the top of the line iPhone. It’s ridiculously seductive to have one tool for photography (and video), audio, email, texting, Kindle library, Seek, and the myriad other you-name-its onboard. It’s designed that way.
Being around a 16-month-old child a lot is helping to drive my current inquiry.
Recently I did a little personal experiment. I bought myself a Polaroid Snap camera for my birthday. I took it with me on a birthday road trip. I was traveling with a friend, an awesome and serious photographer, who was traveling with a small but powerful digital camera. I put my phone away on this trip. We took a lot of photos. The SNAP photos—tiny Polaroids with sticker backs—were a little disappointing (the camera needs a lot more daylight than I was giving it in the fog-dense north where I was traveling), but I enjoyed the process. Here’s an iPhone photo of one of the Polaroids from a page in my very analog trip journal. This was a particularly satisfying snapshot taken looking down at my new book on my lap (see this previous post), and that’s my friend’s hand petting my dog.
Some background. In my early 20s, I started using a video Portapak under the guidance of educator and mentor Nancy Rambusch. Nancy was pioneering the use of video in the classroom to give teachers feedback on their strengths and biases. Watching children’s interactions in slow motion revealed subtle dynamics that changed my view of relationship forever. I had my first taste of technology for the greater good. Years later, when the first digital video cameras came out, I used them intensely to document World Heritage sites in Salzburg, Austria and Jerusalem for a project collaborating with UNESCO.
Also in my 20s, I had a friend who was a National Geographic photographer. So I learned photography from a pro. I loved taking pictures. We’re talking slides, prints, proof sheets. Yes, another era. Pre digital. When digital cameras came along, I took one of the very first…a Kodak digital…to Brazil on a project working with a Mebengokre community on a sustainable business website (1997). I eventually worked my way up to the first Canon digital—I loved that camera for years. I took hundreds of photos.
And then came the iPhone. It was always with me. I didn’t have to carry another tool. All my photos were right there on the phone at all times. It was so easy. And here’s what I’m noticing today. Since she was born, I’ve deliberately put my phone away in my granddaughter’s presence. I enjoy being completely in the moment with her, eye to eye, hand to hand. I’m a photographer. As she gets older, I feel the pull to photograph more moments with her. And I’ve found my phone in my hand, taking a photo a little more frequently than I’d like (e.g., the other day capturing her first moments in a pool wearing water wings—she was so happy!) It’s a slippery slope.
So I’m experimenting. I’m going to model single purpose tools. Next step…moving all my books off the Kindle app on my phone, to a low end Kindle device with the goal of separating out some of the infinite functions the iPhone currently does for me, and spreading out the capabilities across a wider range of “power objects” from my granddaughter’s perspective…so she’s not experiencing me just with phone-in-hand but sees me using a wider range of tools. Maybe her first camera will look something more like this (just an example, not a product recommendation), long before she has her own handheld computer and teleportation device that we naively still call a phone. Meanwhile, I’m challenging myself to let go of the all-too-easy path of one tool for everything.